← Blog

Section 7 Expenses in BC: Who Pays

Beyond the child support table, BC parents argue about receipts. The Section 7 test, each parent's share, and the evidence that wins a claim.

The fight that outlasts a child support order is rarely about the table amount. It is about receipts. In BC, parents who have resolved basic child support often find themselves arguing over Section 7 add-ons: child care, orthodontics, tutoring, competitive sport, insurance, and even phones. These claims are not won by volume or persistence. They are resolved by a test. This tutorial explains how Section 7 sits on top of basic support, how the special or extraordinary expense test works, and how the parents' proportional shares are calculated. It then walks through the recognised categories, what extraordinary actually means for education and activities, and how contested claims involving orthodontics, tutoring, sport, insurance, and phones are analysed. You will also learn what evidence supports or defeats a claim, how prior agreements and family budgets affect the analysis, and how to challenge a Section 7 claim step by step. Finally, we cover post-18 and post-secondary expenses, and when a BC child support dispute needs a lawyer. Apply the test, keep the receipts, and act early.

Why Section 7 Disputes Outlast the Support Order

The table amount is mechanical. It turns on the payor's gross income, the number of children, and the province of residence, which is why it is rarely where the fight lives. If you need the basics, our guide to special and extraordinary expenses in BC explains how they sit on top of table support.

The disputes that outlast an order are about receipts: who actually paid, what was genuinely necessary, and whether the other parent's percentage was calculated on the right income.

Section 7 claims are open ended by design. An order fixes the table amount but does not close the file, because new costs arise each year and the file rarely fully closes. That is why the same argument resurfaces year after year.

What follows is a test applied to evidence, not a negotiation over who feels more strongly about the activity. Three pillars carry the analysis: the legal test for an extraordinary expense, the proportional sharing calculation, and the challenge process, including which BC resources can help and which cannot.

How Section 7 Sits on Top of Basic Child Support in BC

The three pillars ahead all rest on one structural point: Section 7 does not replace basic support; it sits on top of it.

As set out in "Why Section 7 Disputes Outlast the Support Order," the table amount is determined by the payor's gross income, the number of children, and the province of residence under the Federal Child Support Guidelines (SOR/97-175). Section 7 expenses go over and above that baseline and are shared between parents in proportion to income rather than absorbed by the parent who receives the support. For the full table calculation, see Child Support in BC: What the Federal Guidelines Require.

One framework, two routes into court. The federal Guidelines govern Divorce Act cases, and BC's Family Law Act applies the same Guidelines framework through its regulation. Married and never-married separated parents therefore work from the same Section 7 test.

Two components, two fights. A claim commonly has two parts: the table amount plus a separate Section 7 claim for costs paid on top. Each can be varied, enforced and challenged on different evidence, so a change in income may move one and not the other.

In practice, a Section 7 claim usually arises where one parent has the majority of parenting time and therefore holds most of the receipts, but both parents carry the obligation.

Ignore averages. What matters is not a typical Section 7 figure, but this child's documented expenses and both parents' current incomes. The next section sets out the test those expenses must pass.

The Section 7 Test: Necessity, Reasonableness and the Extraordinary Threshold

Section 7(1) of the federal Child Support Guidelines (SOR/97-175) allows a court to order a contribution to listed expenses, weighing the necessity of the expense for the child's best interests and its reasonableness given the parents' and child's means and the family's pre-separation spending pattern.

Two tiers, not one. Child care, the child-attributable portion of medical and dental premiums, and health costs exceeding insurance reimbursement by $100 or more annually are special expenses under the child care, insurance and health categories. Necessity and reasonableness govern, and no separate extraordinariness finding is required. Under the Guidelines, educational programs and extracurricular activities carry that added gate.

The extraordinary threshold. The Guidelines provide that the extraordinary assessment weighs the amount of the expense, the nature and number of the programs, and the total of the child's other Section 7 costs that year. An expense a parent could reasonably absorb out of table support is difficult to call extraordinary.

Deduct first. The Guidelines require the court to account for subsidies, benefits and income tax deductions or credits relating to the expense, and any eligibility to claim them, before setting the amount.

Where a parenting plan should have fixed the sharing rules in advance, special circumstances that require additional provisions are better drafted into the plan than argued receipt by receipt.

The Recognised Section 7 Categories, One by One

Section 7 lists defined categories rather than granting open discretion, and each carries its own threshold.

Child Care

The category covers day care, before and after school care and nanny costs, but only where the care is necessary because a parent works, is ill, is disabled or is in education or training. The connection to that parental need is the requirement, not the invoice.

Medical and Dental Insurance

The child's attributable portion of medical and dental premiums is one of the few categories that is closer to arithmetic than to discretion, which is why it is a common starting point for a claim.

Health Costs Above $100

Health related expenses that exceed insurance reimbursement by at least $100 annually qualify: orthodontic treatment, counselling by a psychologist or social worker, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, prescription drugs, hearing aids, glasses and contact lenses.

Education and Post-Secondary

Extraordinary primary or secondary school costs, and educational programs meeting the child's particular needs, sit here; this is where diagnosed learning needs and remediation live. Post-secondary expenses are listed separately.

Extracurricular Activities

This category generates the most disagreement because it has no price list. The expense is measured against the family's own means and its pre-separation spending pattern, and an enumerated activity is not automatically recoverable.

What Is Not on the List

Ordinary school fees, supplies, field trips, everyday clothing and food do not appear. Courts have generally treated routine school costs as ordinary, covered by table support, but that reasoning rests on persuasive non-BC decisions; confirm the BC position before relying on it.

What Extraordinary Actually Means for Education and Activities

The categories above set the outer boundary; they do not resolve the harder question, which is whether a given education or activity cost clears the threshold at all.

Extraordinary is a comparative finding, not a label. The comparison runs against that household: its income and its pre-separation spending pattern, not a provincial average.

The amount test. A cost the parents could reasonably absorb out of table support is difficult to characterise as extraordinary. A cost that overwhelms the household budget supports the claim.

The pattern test. What the family actually spent before separation is the best evidence of what was normal for that household, whether dance, hockey, music lessons or tutoring. Pattern alone does not decide the issue, but it anchors the analysis in facts rather than preference.

Continuity and best interests. A claim is stronger where the activity was already underway before separation and ending it would harm the child. It is weaker where the activity began after separation or was chosen unilaterally.

Combined income. The analysis considers both parents' combined financial means in assessing what is reasonable.

One caveat on sourcing: BC treatment of tutoring, orthodontics, competitive sport and insurance must rest on BC decisions applying the federal Guidelines, not on Alberta or Ontario commentary. Treat item-level results as fact specific until BC authority is cited.

That framework is then applied item by item, which is where most disputes actually live.

Contested Claims in Practice: Orthodontics, Tutoring, Sport, Insurance and Phones

Beyond the extraordinary threshold, five categories generate most contested claims.

Orthodontics and dental work. These sit in a strong statutory category, but the $100 annual excess over insurance reimbursement is calculated first, so the net figure is what gets divided. Multi-phase treatment plans spanning two calendar years, and sometimes two income years, raise apportionment questions; the applicable incomes and income years should be confirmed with BC authority.

Tutoring. Most defensible where it answers a demonstrated need: a diagnosed learning disability, a documented language delay, or a credible professional recommendation. Least defensible as general enrichment. BC authority on this point should be researched, not assumed.

Competitive sport, dance and high-level athletics. Cost often clears the extraordinary bar, but courts also ask whether the program is child focused, whether the level of competition is proportionate to family means, and whether the expense is genuinely ongoing. Some extracurriculars, competitive dance or sport, and private school tuition are heavily disputed; there is no guarantee of approval, and each turns on its own facts.

Insurance. The child-attributable share of medical and dental premiums is expressly listed. Ordinary life, home and vehicle insurance falls outside the enumerated categories; confirm this against the Guidelines text before relying on the distinction.

Phones, devices and driver training. Frequently claimed, rarely automatic. The claim rises or falls on necessity and on whether the family treated the cost as ordinary before separation. A cellphone on a family plan with a documented monthly cost is a qualitatively different claim from a new device purchased without consultation after separation.

Where several of these collide, a documented position beats an argument; see How Outset Law Can Help.

Who Pays What Share: The Proportional Income Calculation

Once an expense clears the Section 7 gates, the default is proportional sharing. The Federal Child Support Guidelines (SOR/97-175) set the guiding principle: the expense is shared by the spouses in proportion to their respective incomes, after deducting any contribution from the child.

Run your own numbers. If Parent A earns $90,000 and Parent B earns $60,000, combined income is $150,000, giving shares of 60 per cent and 40 per cent. A $4,000 orthodontic bill is $2,400 for Parent A and $1,600 for Parent B.

Deduct before dividing. Insurance reimbursements, subsidies, benefits and the income tax credit or deduction attributable to the expense reduce the gross cost. The income percentages apply to the net figure, not the invoice.

Income is not simply line 15000. Guidelines income starts there and then adjusts, for example for union dues and prior support obligations. A stale income figure is therefore a legitimate basis for challenge, and spousal support interacts with those adjustments, as our guide to when a spouse may receive more than 50% of combined net income explains.

Three complications can affect both the table amount and the split: shared parenting arrangements, split parenting where each parent has a child in their care, and undue hardship. A payor above the table ceiling also faces a discretionary table amount and a recalculated share. Confirm which provisions of the Guidelines apply to your circumstances with a BC family lawyer.

Practically, where one parent has already paid, the exercise usually becomes a reimbursement of the other parent's share. The receipts and a net cost schedule, not argument, carry that claim.

Does Prior Agreement or a Family Budget Change the Analysis?

Even a correctly calculated ratio can be displaced by what the parents agreed to, or by how the family actually lived before separation.

Consent matters, but it is not conclusive. A written agreement to share a cost is strong evidence of reasonableness; a court can still assess necessity and adjust the apportionment. Under BC's financial disclosure requirements, both parents must disclose income and expenses, so the spending record is fair game.

Past spending cuts both ways. Bank statements and budget records from the year before separation show whether a cost was ordinary for that household. They can support a claim or defeat it, depending on what they reveal.

Unilateral enrolment is the weakest posture. Enrolling a child in an expensive, long term program and then presenting the invoice weakens the claim, especially where the other parent was not consulted and the cost is substantial.

Read the agreement for coverage. A clause listing shared expenses, with a cap or category list, removes future argument. A separation agreement or parenting plan is the right place to build it.

Where an order already fixes a Section 7 amount, such as a flat monthly figure for activities, that figure governs until varied, and it is enforceable like any other support obligation.

Evidence That Supports a Claim: Receipts, Statements and the Paper Trail

Consent alone is not proof. A prior agreement supports reasonableness, but the claim still needs documentation.

The core document set. Itemised receipts or invoices, proof of payment through bank or card statements, the provider's contract or enrolment form, and the treatment plan or program schedule where relevant.

Income evidence on both sides. Tax returns and notices of assessment for the payor and the recipient, plus evidence of any recent income change. The sharing ratio tracks current income, not last year's estimate. For the wider disclosure picture, see support and financial issues.

Necessity evidence. A dentist, orthodontist, psychologist, teacher or coach explaining why the expense serves the child's best interests carries more weight than a parent's assertion that the activity matters.

A net cost schedule. Show the gross cost, the insurance reimbursement or subsidy, the tax credit or deduction, and the resulting net cost. Apply the income percentages to the net figure so the court is not left doing the arithmetic.

Reasonableness evidence. What comparable households at similar income levels spend, and what this family spent on the same activity before separation.

Under BC's Family Law Act, a "child" includes a person 19 or older who cannot, because of illness, disability or another reason, obtain the necessaries of life or withdraw from parental charge (s. 146). This definition matters when assembling the evidentiary file for a post-majority claim.

Presentation. One clear schedule per child, receipts tabbed in the same order, beats a folder of mixed statements. What follows is how to use that file once a claim lands.

How to Challenge a Section 7 Claim in BC, Step by Step

With the file assembled, challenge becomes procedure rather than argument.

Step 1: Ask for documents, not conclusions

Request itemised receipts, proof of payment, the net cost after insurance and subsidies, the income documents behind the ratio, and the stated basis for necessity. A claim that cannot produce these is not yet a claim.

Step 2: Test each item against Section 7

Is it a listed category? If it is education or an extracurricular, is it genuinely extraordinary for this family at this income level, or could table support absorb it?

Step 3: Attack weak inputs

Disputed or undisclosed income, credits and reimbursements left undeducted, an expense never discussed, or a quantum above the market rate for the service. Each is a discrete, arguable point.

Step 4: Put a reasoned position in writing

Set out your counter calculation and attach the consent history. A documented letter setting out your counter-calculation may support early resolution before an application is filed. If the same conflict also touches parenting time, The Step-by-Step Process for Changing a Parenting Arrangement in BC sets out that process.

Step 5: Choose the right forum

Negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or an application in BC Supreme Court or Provincial Court. The Child Support Recalculation Service adjusts amounts already fixed in an order; it does not decide new Section 7 claims. Confirm the current scope of the Recalculation Service with BC government sources. The BC Family Maintenance Agency enforces orders and agreements; confirm its current tools and powers against the primary BC source.

Step 6: Watch the timeline

Retroactive claims and retroactive challenges are assessed under the framework in D.B.S. v. S.R.G. Delay by the claiming party can reduce or defeat a retroactive award.

Post-18 and Post-Secondary Expenses Under BC Law

The same discipline applies when the child is no longer a minor: the statute first, then the receipts.

Support does not end automatically at 18. As noted above, BC's Family Law Act (s. 146) extends the definition of "child" to a person 19 or older who cannot, because of illness, disability or another reason, obtain the necessaries of life or withdraw from parental charge. Where the Divorce Act governs, the question is whether the child remains a "child of the marriage." The Federal Child Support Guidelines address costs for adult children, and counsel can advise on which regime applies.

Post-secondary education is a listed Section 7 category. A claim is really a budget: tuition, books, residence or rent, food, transport and equipment, net of the student's own contribution. Courts typically expect the student to contribute from available resources, including savings and student loans. Any grants, bursaries, scholarships and other student resources are generally factored into the analysis before the remaining shortfall is divided; verify this against current BC authority.

Both parents usually keep a proportionate obligation while the child remains dependent, which makes the student's own income and spending pattern evidence in the case.

Confirm the BC position from BC statutes and decisions, cited expressly. Do not import the Alberta rule summarised in secondary firm articles.

When a Section 7 Dispute Needs a Child Support Lawyer in BC

Post-secondary budgets are one line item. The same three questions govern every other Section 7 expense, and they are what decide whether a dispute needs counsel.

When Counsel Earns Its Place

Disputes that resist informal resolution share recognisable triggers: income is disputed, obscured or has changed materially; a large or recurring expense was incurred without consultation; an existing order or agreement needs to be varied; or a retroactive claim is being threatened or advanced.

On a Section 7 file, counsel builds the expense and net cost schedule, tests necessity and reasonableness against the Section 7 text, runs the income analysis, drafts the demand or the response, and represents the client through negotiation, mediation, arbitration or court.

Why Calibration Pays

Over-claiming invites costs consequences and credibility damage; under-claiming leaves real money uncollected. Knowing which claims will survive, and why, is the value of the advice.

Parents searching for a child support lawyer, a lawyer for child support, or a child support attorney in Vancouver are usually trying to answer the same three questions this guide addresses: what counts, who pays what share, and how to challenge a claim. Outset Law is a Vancouver boutique family law practice founded by Oliver Spinks whose services include child support and court representation, so a Section 7 dispute can be handled alongside the rest of a separation file.

Bring the order, the receipts and the income documents to a first consultation. That is the material a lawyer needs to give a real answer.

Conclusion: Apply the Test, Keep the Receipts, Act Early

Whether you are claiming or resisting, the outcome turns on the same material: the Section 7 test applied to documented numbers. As explained in "The Section 7 Test," necessity and reasonableness must be satisfied in every case, with an additional extraordinariness finding required for education and extracurricular costs. The evidence and paper-trail discipline set out in "Evidence That Supports a Claim" determines whether that test can actually be met. The challenge steps in "How to Challenge a Section 7 Claim in BC, Step by Step" convert that evidence into procedure. And as the retroactivity discussion makes clear, timing shapes the outcome: address each expense in the year it arises, in writing.

Where the amounts are significant, income is disputed, or an order needs varying, the sensible course is to put the file in front of a child support lawyer. Otherwise you risk renegotiating the same receipts for another year. Bring the order, the receipts and the income documents, and the answer becomes concrete rather than arguable.

Gurneet Dhaliwal

About the author

Gurneet Dhaliwal

Associate Lawyer

Book a consultation

General information only. This article is not legal advice and does not create a lawyer-client relationship. Laws change and every family's situation is different. Speak with a lawyer about your circumstances.

Your situation is specific. Your advice should be too.

Speak with an Outset Law family lawyer about your options and the next step that makes sense for you.

Book a consultation